The Main Street America Group

Serving the insurance needs of Main Street individuals, families and small businesses since 1923.
AM Best Rating: A (Excellent)

Why Choose The Main Street America Group?

The Main Street America Group offers full lines of personal and commercial insurance, as well as fidelity and surety bond products, to individuals, families and small businesses exclusively through independent insurance agents across “Main Street America.” Main Street America is the founding company partner of Trusted Choice® and one of six carriers that funded the development of the consumer agent portal.

States Participating

Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Virginia


When you talk about an 80-year partnership like ours and Main Street America, it makes a strong statement that everybody involved has done something right.

Gordon Taylor, Blackmer Insurance Agency, Shelburne, Mass.

Main Street America is a stalwart backer of the independent agency system. Other carriers have used multiple distribution methods over the years, but Main Street America has never wavered from the independent agent as its only distribution force.

Bill McCarthy, The McCarthy Agency, Hawthorne, N.Y.

Brand Values

Main Street America’s products and services are backed by financial strength. We offer competitively priced home, auto and umbrella products, as well as a full line of commercial coverages. We pride ourselves on our WOW Claim Service that delivers on our promise of prompt and empathetic claims handling.

Special Discounts

Multi-Policy, Good Student Driver, Student Away at School, Auto Anti-Theft System, Home Protective Devices including Fire/Police Reporting, Alarm System, Smoke Detectors.

Insurance Lines