Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency
Mathenia Insurance Group
  • Business
  • Home
  • Auto
  • Life

Mathenia Insurance Group

Independent Insurance Agent in Saint Peters, MO

About us

Come for Price...Stay for Service!

At Mathenia Insurance Group we are continuously working to provide the individual coverage you require and the customer service you deserve. When it comes to protecting your family, business, and financial future with Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance, and Life Insurance, don't leave it up to chance. At Mathenia Insurance Group, we take pride in our community and are continually striving to become your source for any insurance need.

Personal Lines insurance professionals

Ask me about these types of insurance...

Having the right car insurance is so important, even more important is understanding all the ins and outs of your coverage to help protect you.

Request an automobile insurance quote

Get multiple quotes on your homeowners insurance with one phone call. Let an independent agent shop for you.

Request a homeowners insurance quote

An independent insurance agent will walk you through top umbrella policy options to make sure you have the proper coverage to tackle above and beyond claims.

Request an umbrella insurance quote

Our independent insurance agents will find you the right insurance for your farm that covers everything you need.

Request a farm insurance quote

Why choose Mathenia Insurance Group

States we serve

  • Illinois
  • Missouri
  • Texas

Our insurance coverages

Personal insurance coverage

  • ATV
  • Automobile
  • Boat
  • Builders Risk / Construction
  • Collectible Auto
  • Condo
  • Earthquake
  • Farm
  • Flood
  • Home
  • Landlord
  • Mobile Home
  • Motorcycle
  • Personal Watercraft
  • Pet
  • RV / Motorhome
  • Renters
  • Short-Term / Sharing
  • Snowmobile
  • Special Event
  • Travel Trailer
  • Umbrella
  • Vacant Land
  • Valuable Items

Business insurance coverage

  • Other

Life & Annuties coverage

  • Life

Recommended insurance company partners

Other companies we work with:

American Modern, Arlington Roe, Bristol West Insurance Company, Burns & Wilcox, CNA, Chartis Property Casualty Company, Chubb, Cincinnati Insurance Company, Cornerstone National Insurance, Hagerty, J.C. Taylor, Lexington Insurance Co, MetLife Auto & Home, National General Insurance (GMAC), Openly Insurance, Philadelphia Insurance Companies, RPS, Scottsdale Insurance Company, The Hartford, Tower Group Companies, Vindati

Mathenia Insurance Group Team

David Mathenia - Owner
David Mathenia
(636) 922-5250
Kristin Rubinstein - General manager
Kristin Rubinstein
General manager
(636) 922-5250
Leslie Tippett - Personal Lines Manager
Leslie Tippett
Personal Lines Manager
(636) 922-5250
Cassie Curry - Personal Lines Sales Executive
Cassie Curry
Personal Lines Sales Executive
(636) 922-5250
Ashley McConnell - Personal Lines Account Executive
Ashley McConnell
Personal Lines Account Executive
(636) 922-5250

Mathenia Insurance Group Reviews

Average based on 4 reviews Leave a review

Customer Reviews

July 14, 2019

Mathenia Insurance has great rates and fabulous customer service!!!!!!! Let them help lower your rates too!!!!

July 14, 2019

We had trouble finding condo insurance for our place at the lake but Bill was able to get us insurance just in time for closing. Thanks again Bill!

July 14, 2019

I do not usually do this but I thought I would share my experience with you. For several years Linda and I have thought we were getting too little and paying too much for insurance. A couple of weeks ago someone at work suggested I call Bill Kaatman. Bill was able save us Hundreds of Dollars on our insurance. We were also surprised that we did not have the insurance we thought we had. He listened to our concerns, asked us some questions, and came back with several options. We picked the policy that fit our needs. We now have better coverage and are paying a lot less.

July 14, 2019

They provided my family with excellent customer service and unbeatable rates!!!


Mathenia Insurance Group

Come for Price...Stay for Service!

Request Quote