Collectibles Shop Insurance

How To Insure Your Collectibles Shop

(Protecting your business has never been easier)

 Collectibles Shop Insurance

Customers come through your doors every day to browse and shop for memorabilia, glassware, figurines, signed sports memorabilia, vintage comics, TV and movie memorabilia, and more. Your customers may be able to find everything from inexpensive, kitschy décor to rare and highly valuable antiques or artifacts.

No matter what kind of collectibles you sell in your shop, you need well-planned and comprehensive business insurance coverage to protect everything that matters including your building, your collections, and everyone who walks through your doors.

Collectibles shop insurance is not just one policy. It is a complex and comprehensive set of policies tailored to the needs of your shop and your collections. 

With the help of an independent insurance agent, you can find insurance companies that specialize in hard-to-find collectibles insurance, so you can be sure your inventory and your livelihood remain intact. 

Why Do I Need Collectibles Shop Insurance? 

There are all kinds of unique and eclectic collectibles shops all over the US displaying, selling, and even buying items like books, memorabilia, coins and stamps, rarities, jewelry, baseball cards, comics, and many other items that people like to collect. 

You may occasionally take some of your collectibles to sell at festivals, mall booths, or special shows for collectibles dealers. What’s more, you may store and sell items that are on consignment from private owners. 

The risks to your collectibles are immense, and with varying ownership arrangements and items on the move, your insurance coverage must be comprehensive. 

At any time, your building and inventory can be damaged by fire, theft, or vandalism, and your collectibles can encounter any number of problems while in transit. Your collections must be protected on your premises, while in transit, and while they are being displayed or stored off-site. 

What’s more, you need to protect your building and all of its other contents, your customers, and your employees from mishaps, injuries, and property damage that can occur during the normal course of operating your collectibles shop. 


Save on Business Insurance

Our independent agents shop around to find you the best coverage.

What Does Collectibles Shop Insurance Cover?

Collectibles shops need insurance to protect their inventory, other physical assets (fixtures, furniture, computers, etc.), and customers in a variety of situations. 

Here are just a few of the scenarios that you should consider when thinking about insurance for your collectibles shop. Do you need coverage for any or all of the following? 

  • Collectibles on display in your shop
  • Collectibles held in off-site storage or at your home
  • Collectibles traveling to off-site shows, while at the show, and while in transit
  • Collectibles that are being mailed or shipped to customers
  • Collectibles owned by others being shown on your sales floor or at a show or being sold on consignment
  • Your physical shop structure (if you own it) and its contents 
  • Employees, vendors, customers, and any members of the general public visiting your shop

First, you need tailored coverage for your collectibles, whatever they are and wherever they may be. An independent insurance agent can help you find a carrier that specializes in the type of collectibles that you have and the types of scenarios that you work in.

Talk to your insurance agent about “all risk” coverage that protects your unique collectibles from a variety of perils (not just certain “named perils”). This means you’d be covered for any damage that occurs, regardless of cause, unless specifically excluded from your policy. 

It is also essential to consider “wall-to-wall” coverage that protects your collections (including items on loan from others) while they are in transit or being displayed or stored off-site. 

Your items need coverage while they are in the possession of freight forwarders, auction houses, storage facilities, or anywhere else they may be moved to or stored. Items in transit must be protected whether they are on a truck, plane, boat or any other form of transportation traveling to anywhere in the world. 

Your collectibles shop insurance should include coverage for any non-owned or partially owned items that are in your care, custody, and control but are on loan from another shop or private collection or that you have agreed to insure. 

You will also need a variety of more traditional business insurance policies to complete your collectibles shop coverage: 

  • Commercial general liability (CGL) insurance offers financial protection if a person is injured on your premises or if someone (vendor, delivery person, customer) sustains some type of property damage as a result of your operations. If a heavy shelf filled with glassware falls on a customer and causes an injury, this policy would cover the medical bills or other expenses related to the accident. 
  • Commercial property insurance helps you rebuild or make repairs when an unexpected event like a fire, a flood, hail, lightning, or a tornado destroys your merchandise and your physical space (structure). It helps you replace, rebuild, or repair computers, cash registers, inventory, equipment, furniture, fixtures, and more after a covered event.
  • Business interruption/business income coverage reimburses you if you sustain a substantial loss of revenue or you must close your doors temporarily after some type of covered loss. If a windstorm blows down part of your roof and you must close for repairs, this coverage pays for lost income, salaries, and other expenses during that time. It may also help to pay for relocation expenses if you must set up a temporary space. 

In addition to business property and liability insurance for your collectibles shop, you will likely need a variety of additional stand-alone policies or policy endorsements. Talk with your independent insurance agent to determine if you need:

  • Valuable papers coverage: Pays to reproduce valuable papers, such as financial documents, ownership records, and authenticity documentation for your collectibles.
  • Commercial umbrella insurance: Provides excess liability protection beyond the limits of several other policies you might have including commercial general liability or employer’s liability.
  • Employer’s liability insurance: Covers you if a current or former employee sues you for discriminatory employment practices.
  • Workers’ compensation insurance: Pays for lost income and medical expenses for employees that are injured on the job.
  • Employee crime and dishonesty coverage: Protects your business from the costs of theft, dishonesty, and fraudulent acts committed by an individual employee or a group of employees.

How Much Does Collectibles Shop Insurance Cost? 

The cost of collectibles shop insurance will vary widely depending on the size and location of your shop, and most importantly, the type of collections you have and their value. 

What’s more, your insurance costs will be impacted if you sell your collectibles only in your shop, or if you move items to sell at special shows or exhibits. 

Business insurance costs also vary depending on the number of employees that you have, the weather and crime risks in your city, and the amount of coverage that you need to fully cover your risks. 

Talk to an experienced independent insurance agent who can uncover all of your risks and find the policy options that specifically address them. 

Find and Compare Quotes

An independent agent can work with you one-on-one to determine the types and amounts of coverage you need to protect your collectibles shop from a variety of costly problems. Your agent can get quotes from multiple insurance companies so you can evaluate the cost and coverage options and make the best choice. 


Save on Business Insurance

Our independent agents shop around to find you the best coverage.

Benefits of an Independent Agent

Our agents simplify the search process for finding the right collectibles shop insurance. They’ll walk you through the handpicked policy options and explain the details and options.

Most importantly, they’ll be there for you when claim time comes. They know the ins and outs of the process and will make sure your claim is handled appropriately. 

The Lowdown on Online Quotes

Online quotes can be tempting. They are fast and easy to get, but are they accurate? And are you getting quotes for the right coverage? For business owners, choosing speed over accuracy can cost you.  

Online quotes can’t and don’t see the whole picture. They can leave out important coverage that will leave you devastated if something unexpected happens. And they can leave out cost saving opportunities that an agent can help you take advantage of. 

Instead of getting an online quote, find an independent insurance agent now, and get one-on-one consultation and affordable options for the best coverage for your unique needs. 

Share this page on Twitter Share this page on Facebook Share this page on LinkedIn Article | Reviewed by Paul Martin

©2022, Consumer Agent Portal, LLC. All rights reserved.