Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency
Clear Choice Insurance Services
  • Business
  • Home
  • Auto
  • Life

Independent Insurance Agent in Port Saint Lucie, FL

Clear Choice Insurance Services

About us

Shining Light on Smart Insurance Options

Experience, knowledge, and Personalized Service
Clear Choice Insurance Services is an independently owned, full service insurance brokerage offering products for all types of risks throughout the state of Florida and Private Client Services throughout the US. We have access to over 100 companies throughout the U.S. so we find you the most competitive rate. We believe in providing a client an overview of the coverage options available to meet their needs while staying within their budget.

Our products include:

Home, Auto, Umbrella, and Condo insurance
Builders Risk
Watercraft, ATV's, and Motorhomes
Commercial Buildings and Warehouses
Commercial Tenant Policies
Flood- private placements, excess flood and FEMA policies
Classic and Antique Cars
Large and Small business insurance and Account management
Rentals, Vacant homes, high risk homes
Company and commercial cars and trucks
Life insurance and Legacy planning
Medical, dental, and vision
Medicare Supplements
Accident insurance
Retail and Restaurant insurance

Personal Lines insurance experts

Ask me about these types of insurance...

Get multiple quotes on your homeowners insurance with one phone call. Let an independent agent shop for you.

Request a homeowners insurance quote

Why choose Clear Choice Insurance Services

States we serve

  • Florida
  • North Carolina

Our insurance coverages

Personal insurance coverage
  • Automobile
  • Condo
  • Home
  • Renters

Business insurance coverage

  • Business Owners Package (BOP)
  • Business Vehicle
  • General Liability
  • Property

Life & Annuties coverage

  • Annuities
  • Life

Recommended insurance company partners

Other companies we work with:
MetLife Auto & Home, Edison Insurance, Cypress Insurance Group, Heritage Insurance Company, US Assure, Universal North American, Ascendant, GeoVera, TypTap Insurance, TAPCO, Jewelers Mutual Insurance Company, Appalachian Underwriters, Lloyd's, AmWINS Group, United States Liab, Universal Property & Casualty Insurance, Hagerty

Clear Choice Insurance Services Team

Nicole Allen - Chief Executive Officer
Nicole Allen
Chief Executive Officer
(888) 296-2247
  • CPCU
Michelle Moffitt - Manager
Michelle Moffitt
(888) 296-2247
  • PCSR
Jeanette McLaughlin - Personal Lines Support
Jeanette McLaughlin
Personal Lines Support
  • PCSR

Clear Choice Insurance Services Reviews

Average based on 45 reviews Leave a review
Customer Reviews
August 28, 2021

Great experience. Both Nicole and Michelle think outside the box

August 17, 2021

Excellent customer service. Very helpful and quick to respond. They helped me reduce my premium by a lot!!

August 16, 2021

I was in a bad contract and when I reached out to my previous agent they were not willing to assist me in finding a better rate and simply stating "You have the best policy available" I reached out to Michelle with MyClearChoiceIns and she was incredibly helpful. I found out that my previous policy actually was subpar coverage and she was able to get me proper coverage and save me about $1700 as well. Needless to say I am very happy I ditched my old agent and insurance.

July 15, 2021

Nicole was fantastic! She rescued us right before our closing and got us a great product. She was so responsive and quick and got everything done super quickly. Highly, highly recommend!

June 28, 2021

Nicole Allen is an absolute pleasure to work with. She is knowledgeable, an excellent communicator, and is easily able to grasp lots of moving parts. I'd recommend her without hesitation.

June 26, 2021

Michelle was the most knowledgeable, caring and responsible person. She worked quickly and efficiently to help me secure affordable homeowner's insurance. You have definitely lived up to your name -#TrustedChoice

June 25, 2021

We were "snowbirds" who became residents of Florida recently which brought many challenges. Clear Choice Insurance Services was always responsive and went above and beyond in helping us secure auto and homeowners insurance. Not only did they offer advice on getting new registrations on cars, but when our current homeowner's insurance carrier had the best price recommended we stay with them, and they are not an agent or broker for that company. They are very helpful, fair and worked hard to get us the best coverage(s) for the best price. So glad they are there for us.

June 25, 2021

Nicole and Michelle are first rate professionals. From start to finish they helped me with both my business and personal insurance needs. Not only are the professional and know what they are doing they also saved me money in the process. I truly appreciate them and have recommended them to all of my friends. Thank you both!!!!

June 24, 2021

Kind a speedy service, Michelle got back to me quickly with answers to all of my questions

March 19, 2021

We were shopping around for a better price on our homeowners insurance after the rates increased drastically on our current policy. We contacted Clear Choice Insurance and what a great choice that was! We were helped by Michelle who not only found us a good company with reasonable prices but uncovered an error in our old policy concerning our wind mitigation page that was costing us above what we should have been paying. She arranged for an inspector to come out who provided us with an updated wind mit page and saved us a lot of money on our new policy!! All paperwork was done electronically and Michelle was in constant communication with us via email the entire way. This was a seamless experience because of Michelle and the excellence of Clear Choice Insurance Services. I highly recommend this business for all your insurance needs.


Clear Choice Insurance Services

Shining Light on Smart Insurance Options

Request Quote