Visited by over 40 million consumers
Be Recommended on the #1 Independent Insurance Website
An Advantage subscription increases your digital footprint and gets you noticed by high-intent insurance prospects.
When the right insurance prospect is ready to buy, will they be able to find you?
Works like magic but really, it’s science.
First...
You customize your agency profile
Tell us about your agency and the business you want to write. Then, we feature you in our directory.
Meanwhile...
We bring in the prospects
Consumers looking for an agent are asked a few questions about their insurance needs.
Then...
Shoppers get recommended to you
Our recommendation engine matches your profile to the right shoppers and gets you connected.
There's an Advantage subscription to fit every agency size & need
Too busy for leads? You need Claim-it.
Our patent pending system sends you the prospects you want, exactly when you want them.
Why our referrals are better than leads
We deliver local, high-intent, appetite-matching prospects guaranteed to suit your preferred business appetite.
When a consumer requests to be contacted by an agency, we call that a referral. It is better than a lead because these prospects are:
- Inbound
- Real-Time
- Organic
- High-Intent
- Appetite-Matching
- Exclusive
Getting recommended is a huge deal, especially when it’s by a trusted source
As Featured In
Hundreds of happy independent agents have shared their stories
(here’s just a few!)
Agent Success Stories Mash-Up 2024
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NxLFaE2w7wo&list=PLgzc4kqi1ZraWE4-g7p05D8Vj76LvM8SQ&index=4&t=163s Advantage Agent Success Stories Mash-Up 2024 Discover how independent insurance agents across the country are transforming their businesses with...
Connecticut Agency Success Story – Ryan Keating
https://youtu.be/eyF1DIpiH-k?si=h3_fJ1DK26Y0Z2jC Ryan Keating Michael J. Keating Agency, Inc. West Hartford, Connecticut “The inbound opportunities that it creates are new potential clients that we would not have otherwise.” “This past year, one of the accounts was a...
Minnesota Agency Success Story – Ron Atzmiller
https://youtu.be/PSXA6ww0sq0 Ron Atzmiller Red Rock Insurance Agency Woodbury, Minnesota “Typically [TrustedChoice.com referrals] have been very solid. I usually have a fairly high success rate with those… Between 60-75%.” “Over the last few years, I’d say maybe...
South Carolina Agency Success Story – Diana Green – Claim-it Series
https://youtu.be/gJ_vDtxL9fg?si=BcGSuae-XD6jZh6d Diana Green Soteria Insurance Solutions LLC Simpsonville, South Carolina “I would say my close ratio is about 70%… And that blows my mind… I think that's a testament to the type of leads that Trusted Choice provides.”...
West Virginia Agency Success Story – Jeff Carpenter
https://youtu.be/_kjgFbHN1WE?si=xQh345z-C8IsETmu Jeff Carpenter Smith-Carpenter Agency, Inc. Fairmont, West Virginia “[With Advantage], people have a chance to learn about us without us having to do really anything… Getting the word out for people to know who you are,...
California Agency Success Story – JP Lawrence – Claim-it Series
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fq20fE2BRuc JP Lawrence JPL Insurance Services San Diego, California “Over the course of a year, we've probably written close to $500,000 in premium [through Claim-it].” “It seems like our closing rate usually is right around 45%.” “We...
See more success stories
Recommended Reading
Top Insurance Growth Trends for 2024
Over 42 million insurance consumers have come to TrustedChoice.com looking to buy insurance from an independent agent. Each visitor represents a high-intent opportunity for independent insurance agents, helping them stay competitive in the digital age. This traffic...
How Do Site Crawlers Work, and What Can They Do for My Insurance Agency?
As an independent insurance agency, you’ll know one of the best ways to make an impact online is to be visible. Search engine optimization (SEO) is the formula that needs to be included in an insurance agency marketing plan, small or large, to leave their print...
Growing Your Independent Insurance Agency with Search Engine Marketing (SEM)
Maybe the best perk of operating an independent agency in today’s digital insurance landscape is that potential new customers are just a click away. Though the digital marketplace can be highly competitive, Search Engine Marketing (SEM) has emerged as a powerful tool...