National Insurance Company Directory

Best New Jersey Insurance Companies

Find an insurance company that fits your needs and connect with one of their agents.

RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Farmers of Salem

Real People, Real Insurance Solutions Also: Habitation that’s what we do!

A-
AM Best Rating

“Focused, Competitive, Stable, Innovative” Providing real insurance solutions for real people for more than 160 years, Farmers of Salem is proud to be a regional mutual insurance company ...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Progressive

A+
AM Best Rating

At Progressive, protecting what matters to you, matters to us. Progressive has grown into the #1 personal auto insurer through independent agents by delivering quality, affordable coverag...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Main Street America Insurance

Working Together. Insuring Tomorrow.

A
AM Best Rating

Main Street America Insurance offers full lines of personal and commercial insurance, as well as fidelity and surety bond products, to individuals, families and small businesses exclusive...

Business Personal
VERIFIED COMPANY
PersonalUmbrella.com

PersonalUmbrella.com's system helps agents save time and money

A
AM Best Rating

At PersonalUmbrella.com, your agent can get you a quote in minutes by answering only four simple questions — all without needing a signed application from you. Why choose PersonalUmbrella...

Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Mercury

You can rest easy knowing your family is protected by one of America’s most trusted insurance companies.

A+
AM Best Rating

Mercury has been saving customers money on their insurance for more than 50 years. In fact, we’ve made it our mission to provide our customers with the lowest rates possible while also de...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Stillwater

Know How to Insurance ™

A-
AM Best Rating

Stillwater is a national personal and commercial lines carrier with rock-solid financial stability, ready to be there for life’s unexpected events. We understand that insurance can be com...

Business Personal
VERIFIED COMPANY
Hiscox

Big coverage for small business.

A
AM Best Rating

We are a customer -driven, specialist business insurer with a restless spirit. Hiscox USA is America’s #1 online small business insurer with over 350,000 small business policyholders and ...

Business
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Nationwide

Nationwide Is On Your Side.

A+
AM Best Rating

When you insure your belongings with Nationwide, you'll have the peace of mind that comes with knowing you've made the right choice. Here's why: On Your Side® review Worry-free claims Cus...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Plymouth Rock Assurance

More Than Just Insurance, Plymouth Rock Assurance®

A-
AM Best Rating

In 1982, Jim Stone had a vision to form a new kind of auto insurance company that would create a higher standard of customer service. Plymouth Rock has been steadfast in our unique commit...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Selective Insurance

Be Uniquely Insured

A
AM Best Rating

Through a unique partnership with a network of trusted local independent agents, Selective provides insurance products and value-added services to meet the specific needs of businesses, p...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
The Andover Companies

A
AM Best Rating

The Andover Companies has been providing quality insurance protection since 1828. We are committed to providing competitive, affordable products tailored to meet the needs of homeowners, ...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
ICW Group Insurance Companies

Putting our customers first

A
AM Best Rating

Partner with ICW Group Insurance Companies to meet your workers’ compensation needs. As a national, full-service, workers’ compensation carrier, ICW Group provides you full access to a wi...

Business
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
RLI Insurance

From our niche product offerings to our business model, our culture to our results — we’re different.

A+
AM Best Rating

RLI is a specialty insurance company that helps customers navigate the world of insurance and risk. For half a century, we've been helping people and companies safeguard their assets thro...

Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Encova

A
AM Best Rating

As a comprehensive one-stop shop, Encova is a provider of peace of mind – for our agents, our policyholders, and the communities we serve. That peace of mind comes from the personal relat...

Business Personal Life
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
The Norfolk & Dedham Group

Locally Grown Insurance

A
AM Best Rating

We have been serving the Northeast since 1825 and are committed to providing the best quality insurance solutions for you, your family, and your small business. Our clients rely on the st...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Preferred Mutual

Live Assured.

A
AM Best Rating

As a mutual insurance company that does not have shareholders, our priority is our policyholders and their insurance needs. In business since 1896, Preferred has stood the test of time, a...

Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Peerless

A
AM Best Rating

We believe that buying personal insurance is one of the most important decisions you'll need to make. That’s why Peerless Insurance is sold only through independent insurance agents — exp...

Personal
VERIFIED COMPANY
Business Personal
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Liberty Mutual

You know your business. We understand how to protect it.

A
AM Best Rating

Every business is different, so their insurance coverages should be, too. That's why we take the time to learn about your business — because the better we understand it, the better we pro...

Business
RECOMMENDED COMPANY RECOMMENDED COMPANY
Foremost

A Better Insurance Experience®

A
AM Best Rating

As a specialty insurance company, Foremost® provides insurance choices that may not be offered by other companies. We've spent the last 65 years getting to know the markets we serve excep...

Personal