TrustedChoice.com Logo
For Agents

Agent Advantage

Get a digital profile, improve your SEO, get recommended and get referrals

Claim-it

Get inbound, appetite-matching referrals delivered to you in real-time

For Insurance Companies

Insurance Company Advantage

Increase awareness, engage with more agents and drive the business you want

For Associations

Association Advantage

Give discounted subscriptions to your member agents and increase their digital reach

Inspiration

Blog

The IA Advantage blog, sharing top clicks and insider tricks for independent agents

Press

The latest news releases

Podcast

The IA Advantage Podcast, bringing you insurance consumer trends and insight from influencers around the IA channel

Newsletter

Catch up on past issues of the IA Advantage Newsletter

Marketplace

Agent Directory

Browse our the national directory of independent insurance agents

Insurance Company Directory

Browse our national directory of insurance carriers, MGAs and wholesalers

Live Shopper Feed

See who's shopping on TrustedChoice.com right now!

Find an Insurance Market

Locate an insurance provider for your customers

Support

Help Desk

Get support for your Advantage product

Agent Log In

Sign in to manage your Advantage profile

  1. IA Advantage Blog
  2.  » Agents in Arms: TrustedChoice.com’s Rich History Within the Big “I”

Agents in Arms: TrustedChoice.com’s Rich History Within the Big “I”

From fledgling to full-time—we're taking it back to the beginning! Traverse the TrustedChoice.com timeline, and learn how we have evolved with the Big "I" in recent years, plus where we plan to go next.
Published: December 4, 2023

Every day, our mission as the #1 online insurance resource is to connect independent insurance agents with local shoppers. We do this by equipping independent agencies with the digital toolbelt they’ll need to build their online presence, get recommended to shoppers seeking their specific business appetite, and rank higher on the National IA Directory. As of December 2023, TrustedChoice.com has amassed 25,500+ content pages, over 150 million Google impressions year to date, and recently surpassed 40 million shoppers. But TrustedChoice.com hasn’t always been the online insurance titan it is today. We have the Big “I” to thank for its support of TrustedChoice.com as a fledgling insurance technology company, and we celebrate the history that brought us to our 40 millionth shopper.

The History of the Big “I” and the Trusted Choice Co-Brand

This Big “I” was established in 1896. Insurance agents in multiple cities in the US came together at the turn of the century to create a federal association of independent insurance agents nationwide—a supportive network made for agents, by agents. The Big “I” set the framework for today’s evolving insurance industry, offering an extensive array of services and resources in support of independent insurance agents and agencies, like education, licensing, and liability coverage. In 2001, the Big “I” introduced a national co-brand for independent insurance agents, known today as Trusted Choice.

The mission of the Trusted Choice co-brand is to give independent agents a recognizable and reliable insurance industry name that they can leverage to market their own agencies to local shoppers. In the early days, Trusted Choice would supply independent agents with signage and other marketing tools (pamphlets, flyers, business cards, etc.), recognizing them as a Trusted Choice agency under the Big “I” umbrella and helping shoppers to recognize their business more easily. Today Trusted Choice has grown into a recognized national brand.

How It All Started: The Humble Beginnings of TrustedChoice.com

By 2010 many of the large national captive agencies were seen to be out in front of the shift to digital, posing a challenge for smaller independent insurance agencies. To fight back, independent agencies and their IA company partners banded together to create a digital marketing-focused innovation company that would give independent agencies the online visibility they lacked. Thus, TrustedChoice.com was born! The Big “I” spearheaded the initial founding of TrustedChoice.com, enlisting support from leading IA insurance companies across America, including Safeco, Central Insurance, Main Street America, Westfield, State Auto, and Selective.

Two years later, in 2012, Chip Bacciocco, would join as the new CEO and bring aboard three new IA company investors—Motorists, Travelers, and WR Berkley. By July of 2013—roughly seven and a half months after Bacciocco joined TrustedChoice.com—the consumer portal was launched. The following day, TrustedChoice.com officially received its first-ever shopper!

The mission given to TrustedChoice.com was to become the most visited insurance website on the web, empowering shoppers with useful and accurate information and connecting them to independent agents. Before agents could begin to be found online, however, TrustedChoice.com needed to establish itself as a clearly recognizable brand online, as well as a leader in technology. We did this by diving deep into search engine optimization (SEO) and building out content pages related to insurance questions real shoppers sought answers to online. Each of these pages were indexed and crawled by Google, boosting TrustedChoice.com’s ranking to the first page and establishing the platform independent agents could use to boost their own online presence.

Over the next few years, we built a modern online insurance information resource, recruiting people with the digital and innovation skills necessary to support the TrustedChoice.com mission. It is because of these behind-the-scenes experts that TrustedChoice.com can serve independent agents today. By 2014, just one year after the formal introduction of the site, TrustedChoice.com had serviced 500,000+ online shoppers nationwide. Five years later, it was serving 6 million shoppers per year. To date, TrustedChoice.com has welcomed 40 million insurance shoppers, and that number continues to grow every day.

How Has TrustedChoice.com’s Mission Evolved Over the Years? What Does the Future Look Like for Independent Insurance Agents? 

TrustedChoice.com continues to deliver the innovative services necessary to help independent agents succeed in their local markets. As TrustedChoice.com CEO, Chip Bacciocco, best put it, “In 10 years, the mission has not changed in the broadest sense; it was to bring technology and digital marketing expertise to independent agencies to help them compete more effectively in the 21st century. In the beginning, that included helping agencies to build better websites and to leverage social media channels like Facebook and LinkedIn. Back then, we helped one agency at a time. Today, we are 100% focused on building a national marketing platform for independent agents, which is a much more scalable way to serve the IA channel.”

“In the future, we want TrustedChoice.com to be an open technology platform for the IA channel,” Bacciocco adds, “We want both agents and IA companies to be able to tap into the TrustedChoice.com API and access our data to run their own applications.  It’s evolving into more of a distributed, cloud-based, API application suite. That’s probably where it will be 10 years from now.” With the support of TrustedChoice.com, the Big “I” carries on its own legacy to unite independent agents across the nation.

How Are the Big “I” and TrustedChoice.com Helping Independent Agents Today?

The Big “I” is the largest network of independent agents in the world, and TrustedChoice.com is the technology and marketing platform designed to give agents the online leg-up they need to compete with larger insurance companies. Together, the Big “I” and TrustedChoice.com make up the largest online resource for independent agents, providing them all the tools they’ll need to create long-lasting relationships with customers. With every Big “I” membership comes a complimentary TrustedChoice.com agency listing, which members can upgrade to access more lucrative, traffic-boosting features, and access to digital opportunities.

Every day, TrustedChoice.com works towards making sure independent insurance agents are seen and recognized online for their expertise. At TrustedChoice.com, we’re proud to work with the Big “I” to bring insurance shoppers to independent insurance agents’ digital doors. We look back on this rich history and celebrate the journey that brought TrustedChoice.com together, and it is our ongoing mission to match agents and shoppers while providing the best possible service to ensure your independent insurance agency doesn’t fly under the radar online.

To learn more about Advantage, check out all our subscription options online. Become part of the TrustedChoice.com journey today!

More Posts

The Claim-it Secret You Didn’t Know

Timing can make the difference between securing a new client or losing out to a competitor in today’s fast-paced world of insurance. At TrustedChoice.com, we understand the critical importance of connecting independent insurance agents with high-intent, exclusive...

Your New Insurance Company Appetite Guide – June 2024

Jewelers Mutual Honoring and protecting jewelry since 1913. Founded in: 1913 Headquarters: Neenah, WI What types of insurance does Jewelers Mutual offer? Personal Insurance Coverage Types: Valuable Items Where does Jewelers Mutual do business? States (51) Alabama...

6 Top Video Creation Tools for Independent Insurance Agents

In today’s digital insurance landscape, video is a powerful tool for standing out online. By creating compelling video content that aligns with your preferred audience, your independent insurance agency can more easily engage with prospects when they research your...

Get Recommended on TrustedChoice.com

Ready to take it to the next level?

Sign up for a free demo and let our experts show you what Advantage can do for you!

Share This