Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency
Lancaster Insurance Agency
  • Business
  • Home
  • Auto
  • Life

Lancaster Insurance Agency

Independent Insurance Agent in Evansville, IN

About us

Family owned and serving the community for over 70 years!

As an independent agency, we have relationships with various carriers are able to quote customers with multiple insurance companies with the ultimate goal of finding the most affordable coverage that meets each individuals' insurance needs.

We're committed to working alongside our our clients to ensure that they have the knowledge to make informed decisions regarding their insurance.

We offer personal lines, commercial lines, as well as life insurance.

We're located next to Barnes & Noble on Evansville's east side. Walk-ins are gladly accepted, or feel free to call us for a free quote today!

Personal and Commercial Lines insurance professionals

Ask me about these types of insurance...

Having the right car insurance is so important, even more important is understanding all the ins and outs of your coverage to help protect you.

Request an automobile insurance quote

An independent insurance agent will make sure that your business is covered in the event of a catastrophe or sudden loss.

Request a business insurance quote

Get multiple quotes on your homeowners insurance with one phone call. Let an independent agent shop for you.

Request a homeowners insurance quote

Our independent insurance agents are here to help you find the best life insurance that will take care of those you leave behind.

Request a life insurance quote

An annuity is an investment product issued by an insurance company that provides you with guaranteed periodic payments in return for your initial investment.

Request a annuities quote

If a data breach does happen, it's a wise decision to have a cyber liability insurance policy to help your company stay secure.

Request a cyber liability quote

Why choose Lancaster Insurance Agency

States we serve

  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Kentucky
  • Missouri
  • South Carolina
  • Tennessee

Our insurance coverages

Personal insurance coverage

  • ATV
  • Automobile
  • Boat
  • Builders Risk / Construction
  • Collectible Auto
  • Condo
  • Earthquake
  • Farm
  • Flood
  • Home
  • Identity Fraud
  • Landlord
  • Mobile Home
  • Motorcycle
  • Other
  • Personal Watercraft
  • Pet
  • RV / Motorhome
  • Renters
  • Short-Term / Sharing
  • Snowmobile
  • Special Event
  • Travel Trailer
  • Umbrella
  • Vacant Land
  • Valuable Items

Business insurance coverage

  • Accident & Health
  • Bonds
  • Builders Risk
  • Business Owners Package (BOP)
  • Business Vehicle
  • Contractors Equipment
  • Cyber Liability
  • Directors & Officers
  • Employment Practices Liability
  • Errors & Omissions
  • General Liability
  • Inland Marine
  • Other
  • Professional Liability
  • Property
  • Umbrella / Excess
  • Workers' Compensation

Life & Annuties coverage

  • Annuities
  • Life

Industries we serve

  • Accommodation and Food Services
  • Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services
  • Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting
  • Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation
  • Construction
  • Educational Services
  • Finance and Insurance
  • Health Care and Social Assistance
  • Information
  • Management of Companies and Enterprises
  • Manufacturing - Food / Beverage / Textiles / Apparel / Leather
  • Manufacturing - Metal / Machinery / Computer / Electrical / Transportation / Furniture
  • Manufacturing - Wood / Paper / Paper / Mining / Plastics
  • Mining, Quarrying, and Oil and Gas Extraction
  • Other Services (except Public Administration)
  • Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services
  • Public Administration
  • Real Estate and Rental and Leasing
  • Retail - Sporting Goods / Hobby / Music / General / Misc.
  • Retail - Vehicle / Home / Furniture / Building / Garden / Food / Health / Gas / Clothing
  • Transportation - Air / Rail / Water / Truck / Transit / Ground / Pipeline / Scenic
  • Transportation and Warehousing
  • Utilities
  • Wholesale Trade

Recommended insurance company partners

Other companies we work with:

Accident Fund, Aegis General, Arlington Roe, Bristol West Insurance Company, Erie Insurance Company, Hagerty, Haulers Insurance Company, Madison Mutual Insurance Company, National General Insurance (GMAC), Palomar Specialty Insurance, RPS, Universal Property & Casualty Insurance

Lancaster Insurance Agency Team

Molly O'Daniel - President
Molly O'Daniel
(812) 477-8883
Kimber Sawyer - Agent
Kimber Sawyer
(812) 477-8883
Dylan Krohn - Agent
Dylan Krohn
(812) 477-8883

Lancaster Insurance Agency Reviews

Average based on 5 reviews Leave a review

Customer Reviews

December 6, 2022

5 stars

December 6, 2022

Good place good staff

December 6, 2022

Will do business again with this company was efficient and very helpful with product!

December 6, 2022

If I was going to come up with a motto for them it would be Lancaster Insurance Agency "The Insurance Company that works for you" or maybe " The insurance company where you're family". Maybe a little corny, but seriously. Mike Lancaster has treated me like we've known each other forever and they're always nice and respectful in there. I've been in the office before where Mike and I have moved from talking about business to telling stories without realizing it. Always on a first name basis as well which I personally like. I've gotten unexpected phone calls before as well with Mike on the other end saying Robert I may be able to save you some money. Well who doesn't like to save some money. Nice to know someone you're giving money to every month is actually looking out for you. That's my 2cents.

December 6, 2022

Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value


Lancaster Insurance Agency

Family owned and serving the community for over 70 years!

Request Quote