Popular Questions about New Jersey Home Insurance

The average premium for homeowners insurance in America is $1,132, but if you live in New Jersey, you might pay less. The average premium is $1,092, making it cheaper to buy home insurance in New Jersey than in most other states.

Sometimes, disasters strike suddenly and with no warning for homeowners. Think of your home insurance as a backup plan that helps you stay afloat after an unexpected catastrophe.

Pays for repairs to your home and your belongings.

  • Example: A tree falls on your house, and rain ruins your 60" Samsung TV.

Pays for someone else's injuries or property damage when it's your fault.

  • Example: Your kid is playing baseball and accidentally smacks the ball through your neighbor's window.

Pays for temporary living expenses when your home is damaged.

  • Example: You need a hotel while your house's roof is being repaired due to a fallen tree.

We can’t be 100% certain, but last year insurance companies spent more than $1.1 billion on home insurance claims in New Jersey. That's a lot of unfortunate events happening to New Jersey homeowners.

Insurance carriers calculate the cost of a home insurance policy by asking, "How likely is it that something bad will happen?" The more likely it is that something bad will happen, the more expensive the home insurance policy will be, and vice versa. We call these potential disasters "risk." Let’s take a look at how risky New Jersey is compared to the rest of the US.


Break-ins and burglaries are an ongoing problem in New Jersey. In fact, theft is one of the most common homeowners insurance claims.

  • Average number of burglaries per 1,000 homes in NJ: 16.26
  • Average number of burglaries per 1,000 homes in the US: 24.9


New Jersey is famous for long, cold winters that can lead to serious problems for homeowners, like frozen pipes, flooding due to snowmelt, and roof damage.

  • Most common cause of disasters in the state: Flood

Independent insurance agents don't have loyalties to one specific company's insurance plans, so they can help you find the best coverage for your unique needs. Best of all, an independent agent can give you quotes on policies from multiple companies so you can compare rates before you choose a home insurance plan.

  • Agents in NJ: 475 
  • NJ residents helped last year: 5,790

An independent agent compares policies from multiple companies to find you the best coverage for your needs and budget.

How does home insurance work?

Find the Best Home Insurance in Your City

How does your city measure up to the national average?

National average burglary rate 4.69 per 1,000 homes

National average home value $188,900

National average home insurance cost $1,173 year

CityAnnual insurance costAvg. home valueBurglaries / 1,000 homes
Basking Ridge$2,510$730,4300.93
Cherry Hill$957$236,4727.98
Egg Harbor$693$148,9829.67
Fair Lawn$1,535$445,2501.87
Hamilton Square$996$284,6002.82
Jackson Towship$1,197$353,0001.28
Jersey City$1,336$376,3003.58
Lower Township$723$189,0005.29
Mount Laurel$847$244,5002.46
New Brunswick$1,140$305,8495.58
Raritan Township$1,441$427,9630.52
Toms River$1,003$286,6002.81
Union City$1,011$297,0001.67
Washington Township$1,872$553,8990.15
West Milford$1,097$314,2192.69
  1. $194
  2. Middletown, NJ Monthly average home insurance cost
  3. Average cost of Middletown home insurance: $194 per month
  4. The likelihood of natural disasters plays a major role in determining the cost of your home insurance. In Middletown, winter weather is often severe and hurricanes are a serious threat. This could increase your premium.
  5. Common homeowners claims in Middletown: Damage from wind or hail
  6. After a night of high winds, pounding rain and intermittent hail, you walk outside to assess the damage. Your yard is littered with trash and fallen limbs, and your roof is missing quite a few shingles. Even worse, a backyard tree has fallen toward your home, breaking the glass out of a bedroom window. Hurricanes wreak havoc on Middletown homes, but when you file a claim with your homeowners insurance provider, you'll receive the compensation you need to repair the damage.
  7. Find the best Middletown home insurance
  8. Rather than buying home insurance directly from a carrier for a specific company, work with an independent agent. This gives you the freedom to browse quotes on policies from multiple companies, guaranteeing that you find the best coverage for your home.

  1. $83
  2. Woodbridge, NJ Monthly average home insurance cost
  3. Average Woodbridge home insurance cost: $83 per Month 
  4. Your premium might be slightly higher or lower, depending on the square footage of your home, the home's location, and the crime rate in your neighborhood.
  5. Common homeowners claims in Woodbridge: Theft or burglary
  6. When you come home from work and discover that you've been robbed, it can really shake you up. Your home is in shambles, your valuables are missing, and you feel anything but safe. Home insurance steps in after a burglary to replace stolen valuables and pays to repair broken windows or other damage to your home.

  1. $126
  2. Lower Township, NJ Monthly average home insurance cost
  3. Average Lower Township home insurance cost: $126 per Month
  4. Your personalized premium might be slightly higher or lower. It all depends on factors like your credit score, the size and age of your home, and your previous claims history.
  5. Common homeowners claim in Lower Township: Property damage 
  6. It's another frigid winter in Lower Township, and the latest snowstorm dumped over a foot of snow on your neighborhood. You had been meaning to replace your old roof but waited a bit too long, and now the weight of the snow has caused part of the roof to collapse. Snow is melting into your kitchen, and the water damage is starting to look serious. It's time to file a claim with your homeowners insurance plan to cover the cost of a new roof and the related water damage inside your home.

  1. $108
  2. Washington Township, NJ Monthly average home insurance cost
  3. Average Washington Township home insurance cost: $108 per Month
  4. Rates vary for every homeowner, depending on the home's size and location, its construction materials, and the local crime rate. Your actual cost for home insurance might be a little more or a little less than the average.
  5. Common homeowners claim in Washington Township: Water damage
  6. One minute you're doing laundry and it's a normal day, and then suddenly water is gushing all over the floor, thanks to a broken hose on your washer. You shut the water off and mop up the mess, but a couple of days later, you notice the laminate flooring is starting to buckle. Water damage has taken hold, but there's no need to worry. Your Washington Township homeowners insurance plan will cover the cost to fix the damage.

  1. $89
  2. Parsippany-Troy Hills, NJ Monthly average home insurance cost
  3. Average Parsippany-Troy Hills home insurance cost: $89 per month
  4. Your premium could be higher or lower, depending on variables like your credit score, the crime in your neighborhood, and the size of your home.
  5. Common homeowners claim in Parsippany-Troy Hills: Fire damage 
  6. It's the middle of the night and your smoke detector starts blaring. You quickly gather your family members and head outside to call 911 as smoke billows from upstairs. When the flames are finally put out, you're relieved that everyone is safe, but your home has suffered serious damage from the fire. Parsippany-Troy Hills homeowners insurance will handle the cost of rebuilding and repairs after fire damage, so you're covered.

  1. $80
  2. Evesham, NJ Monthly average home insurance cost
  3. Average Evesham home insurance cost: $80 per month
  4. Your cost could be higher or lower. It just depends on variables like your home's age and square footage, your credit score, and your previous claims.
  5. Common homeowners claim in Evesham: Wind damage
  6. Evesham is a high-risk area for hurricanes and has a long history of serious storm systems that cause widespread damage. In 2013, Hurricane Andrea dumped heavy rain on Evesham, and high wind speeds led to falling trees and serious destruction. Many homeowners rely on insurance to cover wind damage, such as broken windows and missing shingles.